Loos or Laptops

The announcement from last weekends COAG meeting on the roll out of laptops for NSW public schools, has produced a frenzy of comments in the media. While most letters to the ditor raised the inevitable- ‘why can’t the money be spent on toilets’ & ‘ I could get a cheaper deal through Harvey Norman’ I particularly liked the banner- ‘Laptops in schools will be antisocial’- A zippy internet connection? sure. A social network no way? The article goes on to decry the fact that students won’t be a ble to access MySpace or Facebook. Apart from the obvious policy/duty of care headaches in allowing free access- I’d argue that with 1.4 million students in the system, this constitutes a significant social network. With the release of the DET learning tools next year, the students will have access to social networking applications- oriented to teaching & learning.

The branding of the laptos in the media as ‘mini- machines or teenage friendly’ (mind boggles)-belittles the worth of the new generation of netbook devices.

Inevitably most teachers and principals I’ve spoken to, are also taking a deep breath and wondering how they’ll deal with the immeadiate logistics. But DET would do well to look at places such as Maine who have now provided laptops for over 7 years to their students. The practicalities of implementation have been well thought through including students undertaking a contract to take them home and not using them while standing. Also their procurement was an interesting model  whereby the supplier (Apple) are responsible for networking, software, support and training (a deal brokered with only 34 000 students)- hopefully we can get similar leverage with 197 000. Some interesting comments on the experiences- but our challenge now is not to get too caught up in the pragmatics of the rollout- but rather the affordances. Bectas reports are interesting also from the perspective of teacher access to laptops/Tablets. The literature would suggest key benefits include:

  • increased the amount of ICT use and the degree of integration of ICT across the curriculum
  • increased motivation, and hence were likely to
  • supported moves to more independent and collaborative study



About thand

I'm a currently working at NSW Departrment of Education & Training, Connected Classrooms Program, Sydney.
This entry was posted in education, Public schools, schooling, Social networking. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Loos or Laptops

  1. Tony Searl says:

    Thanks for these updates. It is exactly the type of information this NSW DET teacher is searching for, especially the tools component of CCP in 2009. Hardware smardware, give me the classroom stuff the kids will use.

    I’m sure the CLD’s (another buzzword) will be powerful, the XO netbook on OLPC are robust and worthy enough, DET NSW will decide on the complete package not just the individual machine and I await the tender outcome eagerly.

    Yes the 1.4 million DET social network is largish but pales into insignificance in global reality and is still fundamentally limiting.

    I understand why it is so, at present, but I’m not at all convinced walled gardens are the longer term future of learning.

    But hey we have to take baby steps first and these are good ones. BIG tick to all.

    I see my nomination for an Eddie for you did not garner favour with the judges at edublogs. sigh sigh.

    Thanks for the insights, much appreciated.

  2. thand says:

    Thanks Tony- yep agree that the DET network still won’t fulfill the need for students to engage in the real world. In a recent wiki workshop we ran, it was obvious that those teachers who ventured into other jurisdictions- leveraged enormous interest from the students. Theres something inherently interesting sharing ideas with other communities. So lets see if we can eventually move the walls of the garden.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s